Aug 04, 2010 in his recent book, outliers, malcolm gladwell introduced me to the idea of mitigated speech a linguistic term describing deferential or indirect speech inherent in communication between individuals with a perceived high power distance. This article is intended as a shallow dive into two aspects of culture and their impact on linguistics within the workplace. Why would the events of harlan county not have seemed unusual if looked at from a broader context. Mitigated speech is when we speak in a deferential way in order. The korean air pilots and crew members werent direct enough with one another during. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Slps frequently use practices of a mitigating nature in speech and. Psychology abstract this is an article that explores why we dont speak up clearly in high risk situations that require clear communications. Instant downloads of all 1428 litchart pdfs including outliers.
He defines it as any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said. In both events, a series of miniature problems and lack of communication was a cause from the catastrophic events that follow. Speaking as the interpreter, id like to mention, if you dont mind, that im not quite certain the patient entirely. Your completed reading guide and vocabulary terms for. Mitigated speech is when we speak in a deferential way in order to be polite or show deference to authority. Ap english language and composition ap english iii 2019. Learn the unfortunate truths of mitigated speech and how to overcome it, in this summary excerpt from outliers. In western cultures, communication tends to be transmitteroriented i.
The first officer was a korean so he followed the rules of the subordination. Malcolm gladwell speech, which refers to any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said. Mitigated speech is when we speak in a way to be polite. It is essentially the proverbial act of sugar coating a statement. The main reason of the plane crash in guam was a communication misunderstanding caused by the mitigated speech.
For example, if you want your boss to do you a favor, you dont say, ill need this by monday. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on litcharts. The term was popularized by malcolm gladwell in his book, outliers, where he defines mitigated speech as any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said. He began this explanation by evaluating different plane crashes from airlines basing from colombia and korea. What the mafia and plane crashes teach us about mitigated speech. The importance of successful communication between you and. Think of another situation where using mitigated speech could cause problems. After you have read and annotated the speech, listened to the delivery via the audio version, and researched the historical context, consider the primary purpose of the speech. I n the classic mafia movie, goodfellas, we are introduced to a host of characters that represent the mechanics of a mob. What is the significance of practice isnt the thing you do once youre good its the thing you do that makes you good. The chapter attempts to explain why so many planes that crash end up crashing from human error, and not mechanical issues. Gladwell defines mitigated speech as any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said.
The authors idea of mitigated speech, which according to gladwell, refers to any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said gladwell, 194 allows the reader to realize how important communication is to succeed professionally. Being a pilot and coming from a highpower distance culture means you are more or likely to use mitigated speech. What is the significance of practice isnt the thing you do once youre good its. Mitigated speech is a linguistic term describing deferential or indirect speech inherent in. When there was a critical emergency, for the longest time they made the situation out to be less serious than it really was ultimately leading to them to have one of the highest records of plane crashes. By providing examples of mitigated speech with the korean air flight 801 and. Gladwell believed that if the pilots did not use mitigated speech while advising their superiors of important matters than they would have been able to save the people in their show more content. None is more influential than the process of what linguists call mitigated speech. Malcolm gladwell in his book outliers describes mitigated speech as any. Foundations of strong teamwork and communication bc patient. May 28, 20 mitigated speech is communication that is deferential or indirect. In this book, gladwell gives an interesting psychological explanation for why some countries have higher rates of plane crashes than others. Mitigated speech is, by definition, downplaying a concern or situation. Clinical interaction, speech and language intervention, mitigation, defusing.
Describe the connection between the 10,000hour rule and the wetrice farmers in asia. The power of language outliers by malcolm gladwell chapter 7. Mitigated speech in the crash of avianca flight 052 core scholar. The term was recently popularized by malcolm gladwell in his book, outliers, where he defines mitigated speech as any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said5. He talks about mitigated speech which is speech that downplays what is trying to be conveyed. Ap language and composition summer reading assignment. In his book, outliers, malcolm gladwell wrote a chapter entitled, the ethnic theory of plane crashes.
In outliers, malcolm gladwell discusses what linguists call mitigated speech. Outliers on stage a story of success by malcom gladwell. But when you only have a few seconds to make life or death decisions, not clearly communicating can mean the difference between a crash and a soft landing. Dec 27, 2011 in outliers, gladwell refers to these categories as the 6 degrees of mitigation with which we make suggestions to authority. He talks about mitigated speech which is speech that downplays what is trying to be. The term used by linguists to describe what klotz was engaging in in that moment is mitigated speech, which refers to any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said. There were two pilots in the plane, a first officer and a captain. Mitigated speech is any attempt made to downplay or sugarcoat the. Mitigated speech on the flight deck aero crew news. A subordinate from a high pdi country wouldnt feel comfortable commanding his superior to do something, so he would mitigate his speech. Pdf early studies found evidence of a positive correlation between hofstedes power distance scores, which measure the. Teach your students to analyze literature like litcharts does. May 06, 2020 i recently read malcolm gladwells excellent book outliers. The official manual for the program, icao doc 9835, refers to the avianca.
Get a copy of outliers by malcolm gladwell from your local library or local bookstore. This is what is known as mitigated speech, which is any attempt to downplay sugarcoat what is being said194. Malcolm gladwells riveting book, the outliers, peels back the mystery of how culture, parenting, ethnicity, nationality and a hundred factors buried in our histories affect our daily performance. Crashes are more common when the captain is flying. I learned about it in malcolm gladwells book outliers. Explain the concepts of low pdi and high pdi and how mitigated speech causes into.
Malcolm gladwell in the book outliers defines mitigated speech as any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said 194. People who come across as too harsh or forceful communicate more directly to people who prefer communicating through a mitigated speech. Detailed quotes explanations with page numbers for every important quote on the site. Upon further investigation, it was found that klotz, the man supposed to communicate with atc had engaged in mitigated speech, a term used by linguists to. Apr 17, 2011 summary of book outliers from malcolm gladwell. Download a pdf summary of outliers by malcolm gladwell. It results in indirect speech, especially between two people with perceived hierarchical differences, such as an employee and a superior. Nov 05, 2020 to avoid sounding disrespectful, the first officer might resort to mitigated speech, i. Defusing practices as mitigation in speech and language. Colonel william smith, who mistakenly crashed his b25 into the empire state building, in 1945.
Mitigated speech and high pdi influence communication, especially when the person speaking transmitter and the person listening receiver have different orientation. Mitigated speech and plane crashes whats best next. Mitigated speech is a form of communication that is watered down to take the edge taken off so as to avoid conflict. Jul 28, 2019 and how does mitigated speech cause plane crashes. Outliers is a nonfiction book that encourages readers to reevaluate how they view. Think of another situation where using mitigated speech. Write the purpose at the top of your annotated speech in a cogent claim statement. Outlier detection techniques, acm sigkdd, 2010, 36, pdf. It is not a good way to speak when trying to get a direct urgent point across. The term was popularized by malcolm gladwell in his book, outliers, where he defines mitigated speech as any. What is the importance of cultural legacies to being an outlier.
Mitigated speech often sounds more respectful, which is important for maintaining and validating. The story of success the latest book by the author of blink outlines key principles of communication that can play a major role in improving healthcare. Mitigated speech often sounds more respectful, which is important for maintaining and validating a hierarchical culture. The first edition of the novel was published in 2008, and was written by malcolm gladwell.
He defines it as any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of. While the captain will give commands turn thirty degrees right the copilot may only. Have an open discussion about the role mitigated speech plays on your team. Mitigated speech human performance training institute inc. In some cultures, the speech of subordinates is mitigated. Gladwell defines mitigation as any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said. Another example of mitigated speech failure was the crash of lt. Pdf downloads of all 1428 litcharts literature guides, and of every new one we publish. Outliers by malcolm gladwell for each chapter you will have both. Linebyline modern translations of every shakespeare play and poem. Malcolm gladwell outliers mitigated speech hard to decode, easy to refuse see handout examples interventions and mitigated speech too mitigated.
What seemed to be a contributing factor to the tragic pattern was the crews use of mitigated speech. We need priority please mitigated speech in the crash of avianca flight 052. Chapter 7 is about how mitigated speech can affect ones success. Get the entire outliers litchart as a printable pdf. Get an answer for can i have a summary on hierarchy in chapter 7. Mitigated speech is a communication that is indirect. Jun 05, 2020 some of you may have read the book the outliers by malcolm gladwell and may be familiar with the concept of mitigated speech. What is the culture of honor that takes place in throughout. He continues with reference to fischer and orasanu 6, to describe 6 degrees of mitigation with which we make suggestions to authority. The background of chris langan is revealed and shows that his life may not what you expected of a person with an iq of 195. Mitigated speech is a type of subdued speech that avoids direct statements of what is intended. Factors birth year, mathew effect, 0 hour rule, hard work, mitigated speech, power index or distance.
Jargon the speech or language used by a specific group of people based upon region. What is mitigated speech and how does it apply to flying planes and culture. Malcolm gladwell popularized the idea of mitigated speech in his book about success, outliers. The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 309 pages and is available in hardcover format. This refers to any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said.
Coursera real time cyber threat detection and mitigation partly covers the topic. Still, many leaders do not understand the impact that mitigated. The main characters of this non fiction, psychology story are. One factor leading to the avianca 052 crash, which is now studied in american flight schools, was the mitigated speech by captain caviedes and first officer klotz, who derive from the high power index country of colombia. What is gladwell explaining about the importance of communication. The consequences of plane crash in the outliers by. The different perspectives of success in outliers by malcolm. Mitigated speech is when we downplay, mollify, or pacify the meaning of a message.
Teacher editions with classroom activities for all 1428 titles we cover. But overlaid on top of that are tendencies and assumptions and reflexes handed down to us by the history of the community we grew up in, and those differences are extraordinarily specific. We mitigate to be polite, or if we are being deferential to authority. In the novel the outliers by malcolm gladwell, he explains why planes crash and how it can be prevented. At best, mitigated speech keeps us artificially comfortable. Each of us has his or her own district personality. Mitigated speech is any attempt made to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what. Among these personas is tommy devito, a man with a bladedtongue and an oven heated temper, who frightened roaches to their death. The gladwell hypothesis, as it has come to be known, suggests that plane crashes can be explained by looking at cultural values. In outliers, it is also discussed that mitigated speech is something that many pilots are familiar with because when going through flight school plane crashes are much more likely to be the result of an accumulation of minor difficulties and seemingly trivial malfunctions gladwell. Mitigated speech, in its efforts to defer to authoritative figures, sometimes hinders safety and productivity. In this chapter gladwell discusses the importance of proper communication. Mitigated speech is a linguistic term describing deferential or indirect speech inherent in communication between individuals of perceived high power distance which has been in use for at least two decades with many published references. The different perspectives of success in outliers by.
871 1644 624 1201 1004 122 1599 902 558 1713 1217 324 605 649 1362 1663 1077 105 1749 1514 1189 527 1568