Why men fought in the civil war is an excellent example of bottom up history. The way the content is organized and presented is seamlessly smooth, innovative, and comprehensive. For cause and comrades by james mcpherson plot summary. This war is a crusade the origins of this book go back many years. Mcpherson analyzes martial motivations leveraging french military historian, john a. Relying upon letters home written largely from frontline units, he delved into initial motivation for war, sustaining. Edition notes includes bibliographical references p. Mcpherson consists of mostly of soldiers diaries and letters home as to why the men were fighting the civil war.
Doc for cause and comrades book summary turgay ozkan. Mcpherson in this book, noted civil war historian james mcpherson provides a work that demonstrates the potential of statistical analysis in history and the combination of social and military history when handled skillfully by someone with a full respect for the texts and the. For cause and comrades reveals the underlying reasons which made these men want to fight, to be really a myriad of social and political pressures unique to that period of time, and its societal norms. For cause and comrades why men fought in the civil war. Furthermore, for cause and comrades effectually tackles the. Why men fought in the civil war is a book by the pulitzer prizewinning author james m. Mcpherson has taught at princeton since 1962 and written numerous books on the american civil war, including battle cry of freedom, which won the pulitzer prize in history after several instances of visiting civil war battlefields and finding himself unable to satisfactorily.
Infantry being tried by court martial for cowardice at the battle of sharpsburg is condemned to be whipped publicly and. Pdf for cause and comrades ebook download and read. Mcpherson and has been published by oxford university press this book supported file pdf, txt, epub, kindle and other format this book has been release on 19970403 with history categories. James mcphersons enjoyable work for cause and comrades addresses the motivations of civil war officers and soldiers on both sides of the war. The annals of iowa iowa research online university of. James mcpherson, why men fought in the civil war 1997. A band of brothers continuing to look for reasons civil war soldiers stayed in the war, mcpherson further analyzes the concept of honor. In for cause and comrades, he advances many of his points by allowing the soldiers to speak for themselves. Download and read online for cause and comrades, ebooks in pdf, epub, tuebl mobi, kindle book. While various factors contributed to the outbreak of war, it was centrally fought over the seceding states support for the institution of slavery within their. The book was published by oxford university press in 1997 and covers the lives and ideals of american civil war soldiers from both sides of the war. For cause and comradesbravery, its not what you think.
He chose as his speakers 1,076 men647 federals and 429 confederatesstudying. For cause and comrades summary and study guide supersummary. Apr 01, 2021 for cause and comrades lets these soldiers tell their own stories in their own words to create an account that is both deeply moving and far truer than most books on war. For cause and comrades why men fought in the civil war this edition was published in 1997 by oxford university press in new york. Drawing from a compilation of over 25,000 letters and 250 personal diaries, for cause and comrades tells the story of the.
Anxious for the fray chapter 3 outlines how men react before, during, and after battle. For cause and comradesthis book uses diaries and letters home as the primary source of information, however the author does concede that part of the conceptual framework for this book was borrowed from historian john a. The wall street journala stunning, authentic narrative of the war from beginning to end, woven out of totally disparate. Wickham, commander of the famous 101st airborne division in the 1970s and subsequently army chief of staff, once visited antietam. Mcpherson has taught at princeton since 1962 and written numerous books on the american civil war, including battle cry of freedom, which won the pulitzer prize in history. For cause and comrades for cause and comrades by james m. Infantry being tried by court martial for cowardice at the battle of sharpsburg is condemned to be whipped publicly and then dishonorably dismissed. Reviewed by brian wills kenneth asbury professor of history, department of history and philosophy, the university of virginias college at wise published on hcivwar june, 1998. Get free for cause and comrades textbook and unlimited access to our library by created an account. For cause and comrades study guide literature guide. In for cause and comrades, a letter from a soldier describes the reasons that men faced bullets and it states simple manhood, force of discipline, pride, love mcpherson, 1997. For cause and comrades study guide literature guide litcharts.
James mcpherson, princeton universitys george henry davis 1886 professor of american history emeritus, is best known for his pulitzer prizewinning battle cry of freedom, but also noteworthy is for cause and comrades, one of the most significant contributions to the study. In order to read online or download for cause and comrades full ebooks in pdf, epub, tuebl and mobi you need to create a free account. Mcpherson arrives at a different interpretation because he takes seriously the sometimes norid victorian prose of soldiers about. Read for cause and comrades why men fought in the civil war by james m. Drawing on some 25,000 letters and 250 diaries from 1,000 yankee and rebel soldiers, pulitzer prizewinning. For cause and comrades incorporates these themes of the cause for which civil war soldiers professed to fight but goes well beyond them to analyze the full range of causes why they fought and how they coped with the enormous stresses and emotions of combat. Why men fought in the civil war the civil war was the most deadly and devastating war in american history. In the spring of 1976 i took several princeton students to gettysburg for the first of what became many tours of that memorable battlefield. It was interesting to read that the civil war so divided the united states. Pdf this report provides initial evidence that devoted actors who are unconditionally committed to a sacred cause, as well as to their.
Mcpherson this study guide consists of approximately 28 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of for cause and comrades. The american civil war had been fought over the issue of slavery in regards to the national economy and political control. For cause and comrades lets these soldiers tell their own stories in their own words to create an account that is both deeplymoving and far truer than most books. Manhood was a key personality trait during this time, and those who chose not to were looked down upon by others. The initial motivation the union and confederacy sustain throughout the story proves. Why men fought in the civil war mcpherson, james m. In for cause and comrades, mcpherson offers very balanced and researched approach to the civil war, typically a very emotionally charged topic. The initial motivation the union and confederacy sustain throughout the story proves that personal honor is valued more than their lives. Pondering the suicidal assault at gettysburg that history. From the origins of civilization to the twentyfirst century, edition 2 pdf epub book by charles holcombe. Drawing on some 25,000 letters and 250 diaries from 1,000 yankee and rebel soldiers, pulitzer prizewinning historian mcpherson battle cry of freedom, 1989. Mcpherson, 1997, oxford university press edition, in english. Audiobook voice talent for cause and comrades youtube. Get any books you like and read everywhere you want.
Why men fought in the civil war is a 1997 nonfiction book by james m. While various factors contributed to the outbreak of war, it was centrally fought over the seceding states. The influence of the vietnam syndrome on the writing of civil war. Reviews in for cause and comrades the voices of the young men of the north and south sing out to us clearly, colorfully, compellingly, telling us what it was like for themthe battles, the camps, the cold and hunger, the fear, the boredom, the despair, the triumph. His writing style is eminently readable and his arguments convincing. Why men fought in the civil war, written by james m.
Our teacher edition on for cause and comrades can help. Mcpherson, revolves around the experiences of the soldiers of the. Why men fought in the civil war 3 part of picketts division. Bell wiley argued that few civil war soldiers had strong political motivations, and some more recent work supports that conclusion. How the american news media have propelled positive change pdf epub book by rodger streitmatter. In every war, combat soldiers leave family and lovers to crawl through unspeakably mangled human flesh in mud and blood. He has published numerous volumes on the civil war, including the pulitzer prizewinning battle cry of freedom, crossroads of freedom which was a new york times bestseller, abraham lincoln and the second american revolution, and for cause and comrades. Download pdf what this cruel war was over pdf ebook. In for cause and comrades, james mcpherson 1997 notes that, unlike later american armies of mostly draftees and professional soldiers, civil war armies on both s ides w ere both composed mainly. For cause and comrades offers a marked departure from past historiography. For cause and comrades is a fascinating exploration of the 19thcentury minda mind, it seems, that differs profoundly from our own. Before battle, many of the civil war soldiers feel anxious, as the title suggests, though they mean anxious as eager, instead of feeling anxiety. Furthermore, for cause and comrades effectually tackles the most major and longstanding questions of the civil war.
He considers areas of concern for union and confederate soldiers during the war, including. For cause and comrades focuses on the american civil war, which was fought from april 1861 to april 1865 between secessionist states the confederacy and those states that remained loyal to the united states constitution the union. For cause and comrades lets these soldiers tell their own stories in their own words to create an account that is both deeply moving and far truer than most books on war. Battle cry of freedom, mcphersons pulitzer prizewinning account of the civil war, was a national bestseller that hugh brogan, in the new york times, called history. Mcpherson is the george henry davis 86 professor of history emeritus at princeton university. Mehrer uses aspects of vemacular architecture, household archeology, and social power theory to accom plish this task. For four long and grueling years, men from both the union and confederate armies experienced the brutality of combat and suffered the hardships of vigorous campaigning. Why men fought in the civil war and what they fought for, 18611865, mcpherson probes the ideologies that motivated americans to take up arms against each other.
963 877 438 20 391 828 1521 624 760 1461 437 1177 1577 1725 1528 1272 1663 1618 861 815 1141 181